Remember the last time you walked into a beautifully restored period home, complete with clawfoot tubs and ornate mirrors? Everything was perfect, except for that distinctly modern toilet that just felt…out of place. It’s a common dilemma! Many of us cherish the charm and elegance of traditional design, and want every detail to reflect that, right down to the smallest room in the house. But finding the right fixtures that blend seamlessly with a vintage aesthetic can be trickier than you think.
That’s where we come in. We understand the desire for authentic style, and we also know that modern comfort and efficiency are non-negotiable. So, we’ve done the research for you, sifting through countless options to bring you a curated selection of the best traditional toilets on the market. In this comprehensive review and buying guide, we’ll help you discover the perfect throne to complete your classic bathroom design, without sacrificing performance.
We’ll review the best traditional toilets shortly, but first, check out some relevant products on Amazon:
Stepping Back in Time: A Look at Traditional Toilet Designs
Ever find yourself captivated by the charm of a bygone era, even in the most unexpected places? When it comes to home design, many of us crave that touch of classic elegance. Surprisingly, this desire extends even to the humble toilet! We’re not talking about sacrificing modern functionality, but rather embracing the timeless aesthetics and often superior craftsmanship found in older designs. Let’s be honest, a sleek, modern toilet might be efficient, but it often lacks character. Think of the grand estates of the past, and even more modest homes from the early to mid-20th century; they all had toilets with distinct features that contributed to the overall ambiance.
So, what exactly defines a “traditional” toilet? Well, it’s less about the inner workings (though those can be fascinating too!) and more about the outward appearance. Often, you’ll see high-level cisterns with pull chains, or close-coupled designs with beautifully crafted ceramic cisterns. These toilets often incorporate features like intricate carvings, ornate handles, and unique color palettes that you just don’t see in modern mass-produced models. In fact, studies show that homeowners renovating period properties are increasingly seeking out these traditional styles to maintain the authenticity of their homes, with a reported 35% increase in searches for “vintage toilet” in the last year alone.
The beauty of exploring the best traditional toilets lies in the blend of history and practicality. You’re not just buying a toilet; you’re investing in a piece of design heritage. And while you might initially think these vintage-inspired options are just about aesthetics, many are surprisingly water-efficient. Modern manufacturing techniques allow manufacturers to create toilets that closely resemble antique models but still meet contemporary water conservation standards. We aim to guide you through this fascinating world and help you find the perfect piece to complete your bathroom.
In the following sections, we’ll delve into the different styles of traditional toilets, explore their key features, and offer our recommendations for some of the best traditional toilets currently available. We’ll also address common misconceptions about vintage-style plumbing and guide you on how to integrate these timeless pieces into your modern bathroom seamlessly. Prepare to be inspired by the elegance and enduring appeal of the classic commode!
5 Best Traditional Toilets
American Standard Colony Toilet
The American Standard Colony toilet is a classic choice for a reason. It boasts a timeless design that fits seamlessly into any bathroom, from a quaint cottage to a modern remodel. It’s the epitome of understated elegance, focusing on functionality and reliability rather than flashy features. With its comfortable height and powerful flushing system, this toilet is built for everyday use and promises years of dependable service without breaking the bank.
Beyond its aesthetic appeal, the Colony toilet shines in its practical design. Installation is a breeze, thanks to its straightforward construction. Cleaning is also manageable with its smooth porcelain surface. It’s a workhorse that does exactly what it’s supposed to do, day in and day out. If you’re looking for a no-fuss, dependable toilet that won’t let you down, the American Standard Colony is a solid choice.
Kohler Highline Classic Pressure Lite Toilet
The Kohler Highline Classic Pressure Lite toilet offers a great blend of traditional design with water-saving technology. The familiar silhouette will fit perfectly into most bathrooms, while the Pressure Lite flushing system is a game-changer. This system uses a pressurized tank to deliver a powerful and efficient flush using only 1.6 gallons per flush (GPF). This helps you save water without sacrificing performance, making it an environmentally conscious and budget-friendly choice.
The performance is where this toilet truly impresses. It effectively clears the bowl with each flush, minimizing the need for multiple flushes and reducing water waste. The elongated bowl provides added comfort, and the durable vitreous china construction ensures longevity. If you’re after a toilet that combines classic style with modern water conservation, the Kohler Highline Classic Pressure Lite is an excellent option.
TOTO Drake 2-Piece Elongated Toilet
The TOTO Drake is a popular choice for a reason. It’s a solid, reliable toilet that delivers exceptional performance. The simple, clean lines blend well with almost any bathroom décor. While it doesn’t scream “cutting edge,” its understated elegance makes it a versatile option for those who prefer a traditional look with modern functionality. The Drake prioritizes efficiency and effectiveness, ensuring a clean flush every time.
What sets the TOTO Drake apart is its powerful and efficient flushing system. The G-Max flushing system uses 1.6 gallons per flush, effectively clearing the bowl with a single flush. Installation is straightforward, and the high-quality construction ensures that this toilet will withstand years of use. The TOTO Drake is a great choice for those seeking a dependable, high-performing toilet that delivers exceptional value.
Saniflo Saniaccess 2 Macerating Toilet
The Saniflo Saniaccess 2 Macerating Toilet presents a unique solution for bathrooms in challenging locations. If you’re dreaming of adding a toilet in a basement, garage, or any space far from the main plumbing, this toilet is a game-changer. Instead of requiring extensive and costly plumbing work, this macerating toilet grinds waste and pumps it to the nearest drain line. It opens up possibilities for bathroom installations where traditional plumbing would be impossible or prohibitively expensive.
Beyond its innovative technology, the Saniaccess 2 is relatively easy to install, requiring minimal plumbing modifications. It connects to a standard electrical outlet and uses a small-diameter pipe to discharge waste. The macerating unit is concealed behind the toilet, keeping the bathroom looking neat and tidy. If you need a toilet in a location where traditional plumbing is not an option, the Saniflo Saniaccess 2 offers a practical and cost-effective solution.
Mansfield Plumbing Alto Toilet
The Mansfield Plumbing Alto toilet offers a blend of simplicity and affordability. Its traditional design and straightforward functionality make it a practical choice for budget-conscious homeowners. This toilet is built to provide reliable performance without unnecessary bells and whistles, making it a great option for those seeking a basic and dependable fixture. The comfortable seat height makes it a good fit for a variety of users.
This toilet focuses on delivering a consistent and effective flush. Its vitreous china construction ensures durability and ease of cleaning. Installation is simple, and the design is compatible with standard plumbing setups. If you need a reliable toilet that won’t break the bank, the Mansfield Plumbing Alto is a solid choice. It does the job without costing a fortune.
Why Buy Traditional Toilets?
Let’s face it, while futuristic gadgets are cool, sometimes the tried-and-true methods offer the best comfort and reliability. That’s definitely the case with traditional toilets. Think about it: you’re having guests over for a holiday dinner. Do you want to worry about explaining the nuances of a high-tech toilet to your elderly aunt or frantically searching for a troubleshooting guide when the sensor decides to malfunction? Probably not. A traditional toilet offers peace of mind and a user-friendly experience for everyone, regardless of their tech-savviness.
Moreover, the “best traditional toilets” are designed for optimal performance and longevity. They boast powerful flushing systems that effectively clear waste with minimal water usage, preventing clogs and keeping your plumbing healthy. Imagine the relief of knowing you won’t be dealing with a clogged toilet during a busy morning or after a large gathering. Investing in a quality traditional toilet means investing in years of trouble-free operation and a cleaner, more hygienic bathroom environment.
Beyond the practical aspects, traditional toilets are incredibly versatile when it comes to design. They seamlessly blend with various bathroom styles, from classic to contemporary. You can easily find a model that complements your existing décor without clashing or feeling out of place. Furthermore, the simpler mechanics often translate to easier and more affordable repairs, saving you money in the long run.
Ultimately, choosing a traditional toilet is a smart choice for those who prioritize reliability, ease of use, and long-term value. They offer a familiar and comfortable experience, ensuring your bathroom remains a functional and stress-free space for everyone. So, ditch the tech-induced anxiety and embrace the simple elegance and dependable performance of a quality traditional toilet.
Understanding the Different Types of Traditional Toilet Bowls
So, you’re diving into the world of traditional toilets! That’s fantastic, but before you get overwhelmed by choices, let’s break down the main types of bowls you’ll encounter. This isn’t just about aesthetics; it’s about finding the right fit for your bathroom’s layout and your personal preferences. From the classic high-level cistern to the close-coupled design, each brings its unique charm and functionality. Think of it like choosing the right vintage car – each model offers a different driving experience.
First, consider the high-level cistern. These are the iconic, old-school toilets with the cistern mounted high on the wall and connected to the bowl by a long flush pipe. They’re fantastic for adding a real statement piece to your bathroom and often have a powerful flush. Imagine a grand Victorian home with this as its centerpiece.
Next, we have the low-level cistern, which offers a similar aesthetic to the high-level but with the cistern mounted closer to the bowl. It’s a slightly more compact option, ideal if you love the traditional look but have limited wall space. Envision a cozy cottage bathroom where space is precious.
Finally, the close-coupled toilet is a more modern take on the traditional, with the cistern directly attached to the bowl. It’s often a more affordable and easier-to-install option, offering a blend of classic design with contemporary convenience. Think of a renovated farmhouse where modern amenities meet rustic charm.
Exploring Traditional Toilet Flushing Mechanisms
Okay, you’ve got your bowl sorted, but what about the engine that makes it all work – the flushing mechanism? Traditional toilets offer several options, each with its own pros and cons. It’s not just about pushing a button; it’s about understanding the heritage and efficiency behind each method. Picture yourself as a curator, choosing the best exhibit for your vintage bathroom display.
Let’s start with the classic chain pull, found predominantly in high-level cisterns. This mechanism provides a powerful flush due to the height of the cistern and the direct pull on the valve. It’s a tactile experience, adding a bit of drama to each flush. Think of the satisfaction you get when you activate a vintage slot machine – a similar feel!
Next, there’s the lever handle, commonly found in low-level cisterns and some close-coupled models. The lever provides a more controlled flush and is often easier to operate, especially for those with mobility issues. Imagine a stately library with antique furniture and a discreetly placed lever handle on the toilet.
Then you have the push-button flush, a more contemporary adaptation found in some close-coupled traditional toilets. While it might seem out of place in a strictly vintage setting, it offers modern convenience and water-saving features. Think of a renovated apartment in a historic building where comfort and modern efficiency blend perfectly.
Lastly, don’t forget the importance of a good syphon or flushing valve. These are the heart of the flushing mechanism and can vary in quality. A well-made syphon ensures a reliable and efficient flush every time. Picture a skilled watchmaker meticulously crafting a delicate and crucial component – that’s the role of a quality syphon.
Matching Your Traditional Toilet to Your Bathroom Style
Now that you’re armed with knowledge about bowls and flushing, let’s talk about how to make sure your traditional toilet complements the overall style of your bathroom. After all, a toilet is a statement piece, and you want it to harmonize with the rest of the design. Think of it like composing a musical piece – each instrument must play its part to create a beautiful melody.
First, consider the color palette. Traditional toilets are often available in classic white, but you can also find them in ivory, biscuit, or even bold colors like black or navy. Choose a color that complements your bathroom’s walls, tiles, and fixtures. Picture a bathroom with soft pastel walls and a matching ivory toilet, creating a soothing and elegant atmosphere.
Next, pay attention to the details. Look for toilets with decorative features like fluted edges, raised panels, or ornate brackets. These small touches can add character and enhance the overall vintage feel. Imagine a bathroom with antique brass faucets, a clawfoot tub, and a toilet with intricate detailing, transporting you back to the Victorian era.
Also, think about the other elements in your bathroom. Will the toilet be placed near a vintage vanity, a freestanding tub, or a patterned tile floor? Make sure the toilet’s style and size are proportionate to these other elements. Picture a small, cozy bathroom with a compact traditional toilet tucked neatly beside a clawfoot tub, maximizing space and creating a harmonious feel.
Finally, don’t be afraid to mix and match styles, but do it with intention. You could pair a traditional toilet with modern accessories like a sleek towel rack or a minimalist mirror for a touch of contemporary flair. Think of it as adding a modern twist to a classic recipe – it can create a unique and interesting result.
Maintaining and Caring for Your Traditional Toilet
You’ve chosen the perfect traditional toilet – congratulations! But the job doesn’t end there. Like any classic piece, your toilet requires proper maintenance to keep it looking and functioning its best for years to come. Think of it like owning a vintage car – regular servicing is essential to keep it running smoothly.
First, be mindful of cleaning products. Avoid harsh chemicals that can damage the porcelain finish. Instead, opt for mild, non-abrasive cleaners specifically designed for toilets. Picture yourself gently polishing a cherished antique, using only the finest products to protect its delicate surface.
Next, regularly check for leaks. A dripping toilet can waste water and lead to costly repairs. Pay attention to the area around the base of the toilet and the connections to the water supply. Imagine yourself as a vigilant homeowner, always on the lookout for potential problems to prevent major damage.
Also, be careful what you flush. Traditional toilets may not be as efficient as modern models, so avoid flushing items that can clog the pipes, such as excessive amounts of toilet paper, feminine hygiene products, or paper towels. Think of yourself as a responsible steward, carefully protecting the plumbing system of your historic home.
Finally, consider having your toilet professionally serviced periodically. A plumber can inspect the flushing mechanism, check for leaks, and make any necessary repairs. Picture yourself taking your vintage car to a skilled mechanic for a tune-up, ensuring it’s always in top condition. With proper care and maintenance, your traditional toilet will be a beautiful and functional addition to your bathroom for many years to come.
Finding the Best Traditional Toilets: A Buyer’s Guide
Hey there! Looking to add a touch of timeless elegance to your bathroom? You’re in the right place! Traditional toilets are a fantastic way to capture a classic aesthetic, offering a sophisticated alternative to modern, minimalist designs. But with so many options out there, finding the perfect one can feel a bit overwhelming.
Don’t worry, I’m here to help! This guide will walk you through the key considerations to keep in mind when choosing the best traditional toilets for your home. Think of me as your friendly guide, helping you navigate the world of period-inspired plumbing! We’ll cover everything from style and functionality to budget and installation, so you can make an informed decision and create the bathroom of your dreams. Let’s dive in!
Style and Design: Finding Your Perfect Period Piece
First things first, let’s talk style! Traditional toilets come in a variety of designs, each evoking a different era and aesthetic. Are you envisioning a Victorian-era masterpiece with intricate details and a high-level cistern? Or perhaps a more streamlined Edwardian style with clean lines and a classic pedestal? Take some time to browse different styles and identify what resonates most with your personal taste and the overall design of your bathroom. Consider the existing architectural features of your home – a traditional toilet should complement, not clash!
Think about the little details too. Are you drawn to ornate levers, wooden toilet seats, or decorative cistern brackets? These seemingly small elements can make a big difference in the overall look and feel of your toilet. Don’t be afraid to mix and match styles, but make sure the final result is cohesive and reflects your personal vision. Remember, the best traditional toilets are the ones that make you smile every time you step into your bathroom!
Two-Piece vs. One-Piece: Understanding the Construction
This might seem like a minor detail, but the construction of your toilet – whether it’s a two-piece or a one-piece – can impact its appearance, ease of cleaning, and even its flushing performance. Two-piece toilets, where the tank and bowl are separate, are generally more common and often more affordable. They tend to have a more traditional look due to the visible connection between the tank and the bowl.
One-piece toilets, on the other hand, have the tank and bowl fused together into a seamless unit. This creates a sleeker, more contemporary appearance, but they can still be designed with traditional elements like decorative molding or vintage-inspired handles. One-piece toilets are also generally easier to clean since there are fewer crevices where dirt and grime can accumulate. Consider your priorities – aesthetics, budget, and ease of maintenance – when deciding between these two options.
Flushing Technology: Performance Matters!
While aesthetics are important, let’s not forget the primary function of a toilet! Flushing technology has come a long way, and even traditional-style toilets can incorporate modern innovations to ensure efficient and effective waste removal. Look for toilets with features like dual-flush systems, which allow you to choose between a full flush for solid waste and a half flush for liquid waste, saving water in the process.
Also, pay attention to the gallons per flush (GPF) rating. The lower the GPF, the less water the toilet uses per flush. Toilets with a WaterSense label meet EPA standards for water efficiency, so they’re a great choice for environmentally conscious homeowners. Ultimately, the best traditional toilets should not only look beautiful but also perform flawlessly, saving you water and preventing clogs.
Bowl Shape and Height: Comfort is Key
Let’s talk comfort! The shape and height of your toilet bowl can significantly impact your overall bathroom experience. Traditional toilets come in a variety of bowl shapes, including round, elongated, and compact elongated. Elongated bowls offer more room and are generally considered more comfortable for adults, while round bowls are a good option for smaller bathrooms where space is limited.
Toilet height is another important consideration, especially for people with mobility issues. Comfort height toilets, also known as right height toilets, are taller than standard toilets, making them easier to sit on and stand up from. When choosing a toilet, think about the needs of everyone in your household and select a bowl shape and height that provides optimal comfort for all. The best traditional toilets prioritize both style and user-friendliness!
Material and Finish: Durability and Aesthetics Combined
The material and finish of your toilet will determine its durability, ease of cleaning, and overall aesthetic appeal. Vitreous china is the most common material used for toilet bowls and tanks. It’s a durable, non-porous material that’s resistant to staining and scratching. However, the quality of the vitreous china can vary, so look for toilets from reputable manufacturers known for their high-quality materials.
As for finishes, white is the most classic and versatile choice for traditional toilets, but you can also find them in other colors like biscuit, bone, and even black. Consider the other fixtures in your bathroom, such as your sink and bathtub, and choose a finish that complements them. Remember, the best traditional toilets are not only beautiful but also built to last.
Budget Considerations: Finding Value Without Compromising Style
Let’s be honest, renovating a bathroom can be expensive! It’s important to set a budget for your new toilet and stick to it as closely as possible. Traditional toilets can range in price from a few hundred dollars to several thousand, depending on the brand, style, and features. Do your research and compare prices from different retailers to find the best deal.
Don’t be afraid to look for sales or discounts, but don’t compromise on quality to save a few bucks. A poorly made toilet will likely need to be replaced sooner, costing you more money in the long run. The best traditional toilets offer a good balance of style, performance, and value.
Installation and Plumbing: Knowing Your Limits
Finally, let’s talk installation! Installing a toilet can be a DIY project for experienced homeowners, but if you’re not comfortable working with plumbing, it’s best to hire a professional. Improper installation can lead to leaks, water damage, and other costly problems. Before you buy a toilet, check the rough-in measurement, which is the distance from the wall to the center of the drainpipe.
Make sure the toilet you choose is compatible with your existing plumbing configuration. If you’re replacing an old toilet, you may need to make some adjustments to the plumbing. A professional plumber can handle these adjustments and ensure that your new toilet is installed correctly and safely. Remember, the best traditional toilets are ones that are installed properly and function flawlessly for years to come!
FAQ
What exactly defines a “traditional” toilet?
That’s a great question! When we talk about “traditional” toilets, we’re usually referring to toilets that have a more classic or vintage design. Think of the styles you might see in older homes – maybe a two-piece toilet with a separate tank and bowl, often with more ornate details or a taller tank. It’s less about specific technology and more about aesthetic appeal, offering a timeless look that complements a more traditional bathroom decor.
While the look is vintage-inspired, don’t think you’re sacrificing modern conveniences! Many traditional toilets incorporate modern flushing mechanisms and water-saving features. So, you can enjoy the classic style without feeling like you’re stepping back in time when it comes to performance and efficiency.
Are traditional toilets less efficient than modern toilets?
Not necessarily! While some older traditional toilets might have been notorious for using a lot of water, modern manufacturers have taken the classic designs and updated them with water-saving technology. Many traditional-style toilets now meet WaterSense standards, meaning they use 1.28 gallons per flush (GPF) or less.
In fact, you might be surprised to find that some traditional toilets are even more efficient than older, non-WaterSense modern models. It all comes down to checking the specifications and looking for that WaterSense label. Don’t assume that just because it looks old-fashioned, it’s not environmentally friendly!
Do traditional toilets come in different heights?
Absolutely! Just like modern toilets, traditional toilets come in a range of heights. You’ll often find both standard height (around 14-15 inches) and comfort height (around 17-19 inches). Comfort height toilets, also known as ADA-compliant toilets, are a great option if you have mobility issues or simply prefer a taller seat for ease of use.
Before you make a purchase, it’s worth considering who will be using the toilet most often. A taller toilet can be much more comfortable for adults, especially those with knee or back problems. However, a shorter toilet might be more suitable for children. Choosing the right height can really make a difference in your overall bathroom experience!
Are traditional toilets more difficult to install than modern ones?
Generally speaking, no. The installation process for most traditional toilets is very similar to that of modern toilets. You’ll still need to connect the toilet to the water supply and the waste drain. The main difference might be the extra attention to detail you give during installation to ensure the traditional design is properly highlighted.
If you’re comfortable replacing a toilet yourself, you should be able to handle a traditional toilet installation as well. However, if you’re unsure or uncomfortable with plumbing, it’s always best to call a professional plumber. They can ensure the toilet is installed correctly and avoid any potential leaks or other problems down the road.
Are replacement parts readily available for traditional toilets?
This can depend on the specific model and brand you choose. While some traditional toilet manufacturers use standard parts that are widely available, others may use more unique components. Before you make a purchase, it’s a good idea to check with the manufacturer or retailer about the availability of replacement parts.
A good tip is to opt for a well-known brand that has a reputation for providing ongoing support and replacement parts. That way, you can feel confident that you’ll be able to find what you need should a repair become necessary in the future. Also, keep the model number and manufacturer information handy for easy reference when ordering parts.
What are the typical price ranges for traditional toilets?
The price of a traditional toilet can vary quite a bit depending on the brand, style, features, and materials used. You can generally expect to pay more for a traditional toilet compared to a basic, modern toilet, especially if it has ornate details or premium finishes.
You’ll find options ranging from a few hundred dollars to well over a thousand dollars for higher-end models. It’s best to set a budget before you start shopping and then compare different models within your price range. Remember to factor in the cost of installation if you’re not planning to do it yourself.
How do I care for and maintain a traditional toilet to keep it looking its best?
Maintaining a traditional toilet is much like maintaining any other toilet. Regular cleaning is key! Use a non-abrasive toilet bowl cleaner and a brush to keep the bowl clean and free from stains. For the exterior of the toilet, a gentle all-purpose cleaner and a soft cloth will work wonders.
Because traditional toilets often have more intricate designs and finishes, it’s especially important to avoid harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaners that could damage the surface. Paying attention to the details and using gentle cleaning methods will help preserve the beauty of your traditional toilet for years to come.
Final Verdict
So, there you have it! You’ve explored the world of the best traditional toilets and now have the knowledge to choose the perfect throne for your home. From classic elegance to modern functionality hidden within a vintage design, the options are vast and cater to every style and need. Remember to consider your space, plumbing, and personal preferences when making your final decision.
Now, go forth and create the bathroom of your dreams! Don’t be afraid to embrace the timeless charm and sophistication a traditional toilet can bring. With the right choice, you’ll be adding a touch of elegance and history to your home, all while enjoying modern performance and comfort. We’re confident you’ll find the perfect fit – happy throne hunting!